RSS RSS RSS

Defense Attorney In Copyright Infringement Trial Would Like Your Thoughts On Pot, Turtlenecks

Posted by Dan Rodriguez on Wed, Jul 29, 2009 at 6:03 pm

Legal Woes

One month after the Jammie Thomas-Rasset was ordered by the court to pay nearly $2 million in fines to Capitol, another major RIAA copyright case has begun in Boston, and this one’s already wacky.

While the Thomas-Rasset case managed to select its jury in an hour and a half, the defense for Boston University graduate student Joel Tenenbaum spent the day asking potential jurors weird non sequiturs:

Nearly the entire day was consumed with what Gertner termed “one very long, very tortured day of jury selection.”

The questions from Tenenbaum’s lead counsel, Harvard Law School professor Charles Nesson, were, to no one’s surprise… not so conventional. Nesson began his questioning of many of them by asking whether they were “offended” by his decision to wear a Steve Jobs-esque black turtleneck (with blazer) in lieu of a business suit. “I’m a teacher in my normal life,” explained Nesson. “This is what I wear every day.”

Nesson also questioned potential jurors about their views on marijuana decriminalization, even asking one woman how she would feel if she heard during the trial about Nesson’s own (admitted) pot-smoking. She said she didn’t mind, though Judge Gertner quickly made clear that the trial would not delve into that subject.

I’m not sure about Massachusetts, but in many states each side is allowed to excuse a certain number of jurors without giving a reason. I’m guessing Nesson isn’t a total nut, and he is extrapolating how sympathetic a juror would be in a copyright infringement case based on their views on pot and turtlenecks. And that’s about as far as I can figure this one out.

The case itself should be open and shut, as Tenenbaum has repeatedly admitted, including under oath in two days of deposition, that he used KaZaa to download and share songs. Additionally, the labels have a large chunk of evidence and the judge already rejected a “fair use” defense from Tenenbaum’s council. The RIAA will be paid its damages, it’s just a question of how much – and that’s why the jury selection is so crucial.

 

Tags: , , ,

Related Posts


1 Comments For This Post

  1. The Daily Grind Says:

    This case is a joke. I’ve posted some thoughts over on the blog. His argument is futile, and they’re playing up the human element of Joel’s case to circumvent clearly-defined copyright law. Please.

2 Trackbacks For This Post

  1. Piracy Defense Layer Has Got Some Brass Ones | Metal Insider Says:

    [...] is possibly the most entertaining lawyer of all time. First he started asking potential jurors about turtlenecks, then he got bizarrely existential and now he’s asking for a re-trial, saying piracy is the [...]

  2. Obama Administration Supports $675K File Sharing Verdict | Metal Insider Says:

    [...] If you’re having trouble keeping track, this is the trial with the amazingly nutty defense lawyer. [...]



Leave a Reply

  • Death Angel and Arsis will perform free shows together on April 13 in Atlanta, GA and on April 14 in Los Angeles. The pair of free shows are presented by Scion.

  • Bison B.C. is streaming a new song called “Stressed Elephant” exclusively at ExploreMusic.com.

  • The cover art to Sick Of It All’s new album Based On A True Story has been revealed.

  • As I Lay Dying will be touring this April/May with support from Demon Hunter, Blessthefall and War Of Ages.

  • The Haunted will release a new live DVD/CD called Road Kill on June 8 via Century Media Records.